Skip to content Skip to content Skip to content
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
Cart(0)
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
All Services
Selection
Development
Teams
Organisation
Coaching
Research
Cancel
Our Services
All Services
Selection
Development
Teams
Organisation
Coaching
Research
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
Cart(0)
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
BLOG

The Impact of Personality on High Potentials

The science of personality matters to high-potential employees and to the organisations seeking to fill succession benches. The predictive power of personality data can help accelerate effectiveness in high-potential development. But how, exactly?

On episode 117 ofย The Science of Personality, cohosts Ryne Sherman, PhD, and Blake Loepp spoke with Allan Church, PhD, cofounder and managing partner at Maestro Consulting and former SVP of global talent management at PepsiCo. He explained why the impact of personality on high-potential employees and leadership development is critical.

โ€œWhile eachย Hogan personality assessmentย provides unique and important information, the power in understanding the relationships across the tools drives the messages home,โ€ Allan said.

Read on for a snapshot of how PepsiCo uses Hogan, how career stage can affect developmental feedback, limitations that can hold high potentials back from advancement, and four cases for adopting personality assessment in your organisation.

How PepsiCo Uses Hogan

Allan worked at PepsiCo for 21 years, where he helped rebuild the HR function and its leadership development processes. Based on his previous consulting practice, he knew that integrating personality into development was essential.

Initially, Allan learned that people generally believed managers were better at assessing talent than personality tools were. Allan also heard that people disliked answering personality assessments because of their resemblance to intrusive clinical personality tools. So, he conducted about 300 Hogan assessments and individual hour-long debrief sessions for senior managers. Then, he surveyed the participants about their experience. โ€œPeople told us that when we coupled 360-degree feedback with the Hogan assessments, their development experience from just that conversation was 85 percent better than most of the other ones theyโ€™d had,โ€ Allan said.

PepsiCo went all in on using Hoganโ€™s assessments. The organisation expanded over time from leadership development alone to every layer of assessment across their entire talent management strategy.

How Different Roles Affect Personality Assessment Feedback

From first-time managers to senior executives, career stage affects the type of developmental feedback that is likely to benefit leaders most.

โ€œEarlier in your career, self-awareness is important,โ€ Allan said, mentioning worldview behavioural tendencies, derailers, and drivers. Feedback for early-career employees focused on building strategic self-awareness. From the organisational side, it focused on identifying high-potential talent. Can managers leverage their strengths in the right way? Can they overcome their derailers?

Feedback at midcareer levels focuses on guiding and coaching advancement. At the senior levels, feedback helps leaders shape and refine behaviours. โ€œMaybe youโ€™re high [on the Hogan Personality Inventory scales] Learning Approach and Imaginative. If so, youโ€™ve got to ratchet back your ideas or present them in the right way,โ€ he said.

Allan helped PepsiCo position coaching and development as preparation for future successโ€”not just means to fix problems. The messaging about โ€œshaping and refiningโ€ let people feel comfortable about participating in development and receiving feedback. โ€œIf they want to keep progressing, their motivation to pay attention and do some development work is going to be high,โ€ he explained.

High-Potential Development Strategy

Certain personality characteristics can help someone initially show up as high potential and can carry them through other roles. On the other hand, what makes someone successful in one role could become detrimental the higher up they go. โ€œThere are some super strengths and some clear limitations and derailers that can ultimately limit you if youโ€™re not careful,โ€ Allan said.

Those super strengths tend to support execution and performance. In Hogan terms, Allan said that moderate to high scores on the Hogan Personality Inventory scales Adjustment, Ambition, Prudence, and Inquisitive scales are fundamental to getting identified as a high potential. โ€œAs you go up, the relationship pieces matter so much on top of thoseโ€”motivating people, inspiring people, and being good with people,โ€ he explained. Limitations include lower Sociability and Interpersonal Sensitivity. โ€œThose two can really get in the way sometimes.โ€

Allan said that being strategic is also a predictor of high potential, but strategy looks very different in early-career roles than in senior leadership. Someoneโ€™s scores on Inquisitive and Learning Approach can affect their attitude toward and preferred method for generating ideas and acquiring knowledge. Most organisations expect senior leaders to set vision, think creatively, and innovate. Assessment-based coaching helps high potentials understand the importance of social and strategic skills, as well as how to mitigate any related derailers.

Stretch Assignments for High Potentials

Experiences that put a high-potential employee out of their comfort zone can help reveal whether they are ready for senior leadership. For example, these may include crossing a business sector or operating model, leading in different global regions or regulatory environments, moving from an established market to an emerging one, working in the field or in corporate, or adjusting to a cross-functional role.

Personality assessment data can help high potentials navigate their new, highly stressful dynamic environment. โ€œBy definition, a stretch assignment should give you stress. Why in the world wouldnโ€™t we sit down and remind you of your derailers?โ€ Allan said.

From an organisational standpoint, stretch assignments for high-potential development can help reveal opportunities for tactical team building. Demanding that someone with a low Inquisitive score instantly excel in a job that requires strategic thinking could be detrimental. Instead, organisations can support that potential gap with skilled lieutenants, a coach, and mentors to help the person learn.

A High-Potential Development Success Story

Allan shared a story about a junior marketer at PepsiCo who was smart and driven. This high-potential employee had higher scores on Adjustment and Ambition and very low scores on Sociability. โ€œIf you want to be a CEO one day, youโ€™re going to have to overcome your natural tendency to resist visibility and being social,โ€ Allan told them. They also had very high scores on the Hogan Development Surveyโ€™s Bold scale. The Bold scale concerns seeming entitled, arrogant, and overconfident. Based on the Hogan debrief and assessment-based coaching that Allan gave this person, they gained strategic self-awareness. They advanced to CMO and ultimately president of one of the companyโ€™s biggest divisions.

Advice for Adopting Personality Assessment

Be clear about why youโ€™re considering integrating personality assessment. Allan described four cases you can use to persuade your organisation that assessment is valuable.

  1. The business caseย โ€“ The science of personality has an impact on how our people lead and manage, which in turn has an impact on success.
  2. The talent decision-making caseย โ€“ We can use this data to make better people decisions, to select people, to develop people, to form teams, to plan for succession . . .
  3. The organisational development caseย โ€“ If we embed personality into how we do things, we can build a better, more development-focused culture.
  4. The leadership caseย โ€“ Personality assessment data will help predict success and augment all the leadership work that we do.

The bottom line? โ€œAn overall language of leadership, personality, and impact is critical for all leadership development,โ€ Allan said.

Listen to this conversation in full onย episode 117ย ofย The Science of Personality.

*This blog was originally published onย Hogan Assessments

References

TOPIC AREA

DATE POSTED

January 22, 2025

SHARE ON YOUR SOCIALS

Latest blog posts

Loading...

The Dark Side of Creativity: How Imagination Derails Performance

Predicting Athletic Performance with Personality Assessment

PBC Webinar – Measuring What Matters: A Smarter Way to Lead Safer Workplaces

Webinar: Customising the Hogan 360: Why, When and How

Enabling the SES Performance Leadership Framework through leveraging the Hogan 360 in Development

Questions?

Weโ€™re here
to help.

Contact Us

Get certified
today

Gain comprehensive training on how to use Hoganโ€™s personality assessments

Get Certified Now

Related Articles

The Dark Side of Creativity: How Imagination Derails Performance

Most of us have encountered a leader who uses meetings as personal brainstorming time. Everyone leaves feeling confused or uncertain…
Read More

Predicting Athletic Performance with Personality Assessment

Can personality predict the success of professional athletes? Whether helping NBA teams predict rookie-year performance or NFL teams perfect their…
Read More

PBC Webinar – Measuring What Matters: A Smarter Way to Lead Safer Workplaces

๐Ÿ“…13 November 2025 ๐Ÿ•‘12:30-1:30 PM (AEDT) | 2:30-3:30 PM (NZDT) Join Dr. Xander Van Lill and Andrew Morris on 30…
Read More
View All

Stay connected

Copyright 2024 Peter Berry Consultancy.

Sydney

Level 8/201 Miller Street,
North Sydney, NSW 2060 Australia

Phone: +61 2 8918 0888

Peter Berry Consultancy wishes to acknowledge the Traditional Custodians the Cammeraygal and their Country on which we work today.

See map

Melbourne

Suite 303, 430 Little Collins Street, Melbourne, VIC, 3000 Australia

Phone: +61 3 8629 5100

Peter Berry Consultancy wishes to acknowledge the Traditional Custodians the Boon Wurrung and Woiwurrung (Wurundjeri) peoples of the Kulin Nation and their Country on which we work today.

See map

Auckland

11 Britomart Place, Auckland CBD,
Auckland 1010, New Zealand

Phone: +64 9 941 9790

See map

Ireland

Suite 301, 53 Merrion Square South, Dublin 2, D02 PR63, Ireland

Phone: +353 1 578 3607

See map
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
Peter Berry Consultancy
Manage Consent

PBC uses cookies. Learn more about our policies by clicking the links below.

Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}