Skip to content Skip to content Skip to content
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
Cart(0)
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
All Services
Selection
Development
Teams
Organisation
Coaching
Research
Cancel
Our Services
All Services
Selection
Development
Teams
Organisation
Coaching
Research
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
Cart(0)
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
BLOG

The Superstar Effect

Superstar workers arenโ€™t always as good as they seem. When other high performers must compete with superstars, they can become demotivated. This is known as the superstar effect, and it can have a significant impact on teams and organisations.

Recently onย The Science of Personality, cohostsย Ryne Sherman, PhD, chief science officer, andย Blake Loepp, PR manager, explored the superstar effect and how it relates to teams and organisations.

Letโ€™s dive into what to do about the problem of superstars.

What Is the Superstar Effect?

A superstar is a top performer. โ€œThe presence of a superstar impacts the performance of other people around themโ€”often in a negative way,โ€ Ryne explained. Just having a superstar nearby, whether on the same team or not, can hinder performance.

Record-breaking golfer Tiger Woods is an example of a superstar. Theย study that introduced the psychological phenomenonย analysed the performance of top golfers with respect to the presence of Woods. When he was in the field, his opponents shot worse on average than when he wasnโ€™t in the field. The mere fact of his presence seemed to drive down the performance of all of the competition. Even more remarkably, the stroke average of the best players was impacted more dramatically than that of average performers.

All possible explanations for this effect are mental. Perhaps the other golfers took more risks in trying to beat Woods. They also might have felt extra pressure because each shot matters more when competing against a superstar. Or they might have felt intimidated by Woodsโ€™s more eager and comparatively aggressive playing style, asย golfer Ernie Els suggested.

We see the superstar effect in competitive chess, as well. Against the current world champion, Magnus Carlsen, most of the top players perform slightly worse than they do against other competitors. When Carlsen makes a move that looks like a mistake, other top players assume it is not an error but a complex play. What they should do is recognise the mistake and take advantage of it.

How Superstars Impact Teams

Imagine that, instead of Woods or Carlsen crushing individual competition, a top-performing sales rep or a hotshot lawyer is introduced into a new team. How does the presence of a superstar impact overallย team performanceย in a corporate setting?

โ€œThe team on average may improve because the superstar is adding so much value, but individuals on that team might have lower performance because of the presence of that superstar,โ€ Ryne said.

The superstar effect is a counterintuitive phenomenon. You would think that, with the addition of a high-performing team member, everyone else would rise to the challenge, so to speak. But when the skill gap is too great, others can feel fearful, intimidated, inferior, or defeated. The superstar effect could bring outย employeesโ€™ย derailersย as they look for other ways to get ahead.

Another example of the superstar effect comes from the TV seriesย Billionsย on Showtime. Intern Taylor Mason, whose investment prowess gains the notice of the main character and the consternation of the team members, is a corporate superstar. โ€œYou could see this psychological effect on the rest of these otherwise very successful investors and how it had a negative impact on their overall performance,โ€ Blake explained.

What Organisations Can Do

If the presence of superstars is so detrimental to teams, is it better not to hire them at all? Not necessarily.

First, be realistic about the superstar effect.

Superstars can certainly add a lot of value, but maybe not as much as it first appears. A toxic worker isย much more detrimentalย than a superstar worker is beneficial, for example. By that measure, an average team performs better than a team with one superstar and one toxic worker.

Second, redirect superstarsโ€™ competitive natures.

If your organisation thrives on internal competition, the superstar effect will likely hurt productivity. But if competition is correctly reframed as external, there could be a good result: the superstar could impact organisational competition adversely, not team members.

The superstar effect makes competitors feel that they canโ€™t beat the star. Consider how it would have felt to compete against entrepreneur Steve Jobs at Apple in the 2000s. Or think of competing against Michael Jordan on various basketball teams in the 1990s.

For organisations to integrate superstars intoย teams successfully, defining the competition is key. Hypercompetitive people want to compete with everyone, but that tendency can be directed outward,ย protecting team membersย from competing among themselves.

โ€œSmart organisations can use the superstar effect to their advantage in a positive way,โ€ Ryne said.

Listen to this conversation in full onย episode 56ย ofย The Science of Personality. Never miss an episode by following us anywhere you get podcasts. Cheers, everybody!

Contact us for more informationย Learn about the Hogan 360

References

This blog post was originally posted byย Hogan Assessments

TOPIC AREA

HPTA, Personality, Teams

DATE POSTED

August 17, 2022

SHARE ON YOUR SOCIALS

Latest blog posts

Loading...

Predicting Athletic Performance with Personality Assessment

PBC Webinar – Measuring What Matters: A Smarter Way to Lead Safer Workplaces

Webinar: Customising the Hogan 360: Why, When and How

Enabling the SES Performance Leadership Framework through leveraging the Hogan 360 in Development

Rethinking Leadership: The Core5 Model of Leadership Effectiveness

Questions?

Weโ€™re here
to help.

Contact Us

Get certified
today

Gain comprehensive training on how to use Hoganโ€™s personality assessments

Get Certified Now

Related Articles

Predicting Athletic Performance with Personality Assessment

Can personality predict the success of professional athletes? Whether helping NBA teams predict rookie-year performance or NFL teams perfect their…
Read More

PBC Webinar – Measuring What Matters: A Smarter Way to Lead Safer Workplaces

๐Ÿ“…30 October 2025 ๐Ÿ•‘10:00-11:00 AM (AEDT) | 12:00-1:00 PM (NZDT) Join Dr. Xander Van Lill and Andrew Morris on 30…
Read More

Webinar: Customising the Hogan 360: Why, When and How

The Hogan 360 is a powerful feedback tool, and customisation can make it even more relevant and impactful for your…
Read More
View All

Stay connected

Copyright 2024 Peter Berry Consultancy.

Sydney

Level 8/201 Miller Street,
North Sydney, NSW 2060 Australia

Phone: +61 2 8918 0888

Peter Berry Consultancy wishes to acknowledge the Traditional Custodians the Cammeraygal and their Country on which we work today.

See map

Melbourne

Suite 303, 430 Little Collins Street, Melbourne, VIC, 3000 Australia

Phone: +61 3 8629 5100

Peter Berry Consultancy wishes to acknowledge the Traditional Custodians the Boon Wurrung and Woiwurrung (Wurundjeri) peoples of the Kulin Nation and their Country on which we work today.

See map

Auckland

11 Britomart Place, Auckland CBD,
Auckland 1010, New Zealand

Phone: +64 9 941 9790

See map

Ireland

Suite 301, 53 Merrion Square South, Dublin 2, D02 PR63, Ireland

Phone: +353 1 578 3607

See map
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
Peter Berry Consultancy
Manage Consent

PBC uses cookies. Learn more about our policies by clicking the links below.

Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}