Skip to content Skip to content Skip to content
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
Cart(0)
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
All Services
Selection
Development
Teams
Organisation
Coaching
Research
Cancel
Our Services
All Services
Selection
Development
Teams
Organisation
Coaching
Research
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
Cart(0)
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
BLOG

AI in Psychology

Leadership consultants, executive coaches, industrial-organisational psychologists, and artificial intelligence all have the same goal: to help make people better at what they do. Do you agree? Recently onย The Science of Personality, cohostsย Ryne Sherman, PhD, chief science officer, andย Blake Loepp, PR manager, spoke withย Ted Hayes, PhD, a research psychologist in northern Virginia, about the implications of using AI in consulting psychology.

โ€œAI is where the future is, and we are moving into the future. You canโ€™t avoid AI,โ€ Ted said.

Letโ€™s dive into a comparison of the strengths and weaknesses of AI coaching and human coaching respectively, as well as our guestโ€™s advice for coaches.

AI Transformation Is Inevitable

Artificial intelligence, machine learning, and deep learning will become part of the fabric of just about every industry, including consulting psychology and leadership coaching. AI will affect our futuresโ€”and the outlook is bright. Ted pointed out that effecting successful technological change will draw upon the socioemotional skills of leaders to provide change management andย psychological safety. It will also draw upon the expertise of psychologists during a time when every single organisational function is likely to be affected by AI.

Before we start imagining evil AI overlords dictating every minute of our working lives, itโ€™s important to note that humans produce and control the content upon which AI is based. Ted explained AI โ€œcreativityโ€ using two terms: generative AI and discriminative AI. Generative AI takes existing content and produces variations, such as ChatGPT inventing a comic book superhero based on Wonder Woman. Discriminative AI is a more predictive tool, which might identify employees who may become high-potential leaders or candidates who merit a second interview.

In the case of discriminative AI, an industry concern is that, while psychologists must follow guidelines, laws, rules, and regulations, AI tools behave the way theyโ€™ve been programmed. They donโ€™t have accountability the same way that people do. Instead, AI has guardrails programmed into it by humanย engineers and data scientistsย who can choose to limit its access to information and its influence within the organisation.

Reiterating that AI is answerable only to its programming, Ted observed, โ€œOn the one hand, AI wonโ€™t save us from ourselves. On the other hand, itโ€™ll reflect the best of us if thatโ€™s how we set up its content, and we are in control of that.โ€

 

AI Coaching vs. Human Coaching

In the consulting and coaching realm, AI coaching can offer some benefits that humans cannot. Machines are excellent at providing unrelentingย reliabilityย and processing data. In terms of the inability to like or dislike, they lack bias. They can help to train and support leaders and teams with instruction or data analysis. โ€œIt could do a lot in terms of developing peopleโ€”not because it likes people, but because its imperative is to make people better at what they do,โ€ Ted said.

Other benefits are that AI is always awake and accessible. It canโ€™t get tired or distracted. It can learn a lot about you and make recommendations based on the data you provide to it, including how to achieve career goals. The advice is personalized. Even if it canโ€™t contextualize or react to your emotions, it can choose a different option based on your response.

Now, human psychologists, consultants, and coaches currently have and always will have certain advantages over AI. If AI has some tools, a human coach has a wealth of tools, including AI. Humans understand how to leverage those tools relative to client needs.

An AI coach is likely to advise more broadly than a human. A humanโ€™s emotions and life experiences will allow greater specificity. Put another way, some scenarios will be so specific that where the AI might rely on data about it, the human has lived it.

Learning to position AI effectively will be a process. โ€œWeโ€™re right at the dawn of all this. We just donโ€™t know how good itโ€™s going to get,โ€ said Ted.

 

The Human Connection

A one-on-one, human-to-human interactiveย coaching sessionย isnโ€™t possible with an AI-powered coach. Perhaps surprisingly, however, there are some positives to coaching without the human connection. First, AI is without emotion, so how it feels about you cannot affect how it behaves. Second, AI cannot decide to lie to you because it has no metacognition. It is also superior to humans in its capacity to process information as an analytical function and to present information as a pedagogical function.

On the other hand, there are drawbacks to losing that human connection. One drawback is that data are messy, and AI using messy data might discriminate or generate racist, sexist, or homophobic responses. AI-powered systems require constant vigilance to achieve positive outcomes, and this need for oversight can be a downside.

Another drawback to AI coaching is the very absence of emotion. People tend to humanize machines. An AI coach or assistant, however, simply cannot answer many of the questions we might ask it. It could rate the pros and cons of a decision, but it canโ€™t always know what is right.

Data privacy is another negative association with using AI tools. If an AI system construed personality information from an interview, for example, then it would be essential for the human to know how those data might be used for selection. An AI that collects information about organisational citizenship across platforms over time is another potentially privacy-violating example.

The human connection remains essential. Assessment feedback from a coach or psychologist trained in dealing with people and organisations will necessarily be superior to that provided by an AI. An AI system only knows whatโ€™s in its database. It canโ€™tย notice a reactionย from a person and couch information in a certain way to be supportive because it cannot care. โ€œHumans still have the upper hand, especially psychologists, in leveraging their expertise relative to what an AI system can do in terms of working with people,โ€ said Ted.

 

Advice for Coaches

Ted suggested how coaches and consultants should respond to new technologies with a mindset focused on those they support.

Challenge your thinking about how to partner with AI in your journey as a consultant, psychologist, or coach. Choose to learn about ways to apply AI. Understand the ethical implications of working with AI systems in assessment and leadership development . Imagine how you would function inside an organisation that valued human behaviour enough to understand it through an AI platform.

Add value to the individuals in organisations and societies that choose to build out their AI function. โ€œI understand the reasons to be pessimistic, but I donโ€™t share them,โ€ Ted concluded. โ€œWe can avoid issues like not accounting for algorithmic bias, for not treating people with dignity and respect as they deal with an AI system, for not understanding the possible environmental consequences of having an AI-based system. Because we are accountable, we can do that, and that sets us apart.โ€

Listen to this conversation in full on episode 71 ofย The Science of Personality. Never miss an episode by following us anywhere you get podcasts.

Contact us for more informationย Get Certified

References

This post was originally published onย Hoganย Assessments

TOPIC AREA

AI, Artificial Intelligence, Psychology

DATE POSTED

June 19, 2023

SHARE ON YOUR SOCIALS

Latest blog posts

Loading...

The Dark Side of Creativity: How Imagination Derails Performance

Predicting Athletic Performance with Personality Assessment

PBC Webinar – Measuring What Matters: A Smarter Way to Lead Safer Workplaces

Webinar: Customising the Hogan 360: Why, When and How

Enabling the SES Performance Leadership Framework through leveraging the Hogan 360 in Development

Questions?

Weโ€™re here
to help.

Contact Us

Get certified
today

Gain comprehensive training on how to use Hoganโ€™s personality assessments

Get Certified Now

Related Articles

The Dark Side of Creativity: How Imagination Derails Performance

Most of us have encountered a leader who uses meetings as personal brainstorming time. Everyone leaves feeling confused or uncertain…
Read More

Predicting Athletic Performance with Personality Assessment

Can personality predict the success of professional athletes? Whether helping NBA teams predict rookie-year performance or NFL teams perfect their…
Read More

PBC Webinar – Measuring What Matters: A Smarter Way to Lead Safer Workplaces

๐Ÿ“…30 October 2025 ๐Ÿ•‘10:00-11:00 AM (AEDT) | 12:00-1:00 PM (NZDT) Join Dr. Xander Van Lill and Andrew Morris on 30…
Read More
View All

Stay connected

Copyright 2024 Peter Berry Consultancy.

Sydney

Level 8/201 Miller Street,
North Sydney, NSW 2060 Australia

Phone: +61 2 8918 0888

Peter Berry Consultancy wishes to acknowledge the Traditional Custodians the Cammeraygal and their Country on which we work today.

See map

Melbourne

Suite 303, 430 Little Collins Street, Melbourne, VIC, 3000 Australia

Phone: +61 3 8629 5100

Peter Berry Consultancy wishes to acknowledge the Traditional Custodians the Boon Wurrung and Woiwurrung (Wurundjeri) peoples of the Kulin Nation and their Country on which we work today.

See map

Auckland

11 Britomart Place, Auckland CBD,
Auckland 1010, New Zealand

Phone: +64 9 941 9790

See map

Ireland

Suite 301, 53 Merrion Square South, Dublin 2, D02 PR63, Ireland

Phone: +353 1 578 3607

See map
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
Peter Berry Consultancy
Manage Consent

PBC uses cookies. Learn more about our policies by clicking the links below.

Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}