Skip to content Skip to content Skip to content
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
Cart(0)
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
All Services
Selection
Development
Teams
Organisation
Coaching
Research
Cancel
Our Services
All Services
Selection
Development
Teams
Organisation
Coaching
Research
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
  • Our Services
  • Assessments
  • Certifications
  • Resources
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Get Certified
Cart(0)
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
  • About PBC
  • About Hogan
  • Blog
BLOG

CEO Behaviour

Are luxury possessions and speeding tickets indicative of CEOs who will cultivate scandal and commit fraud? They can be. Recently onย The Science of Personality, cohostsย Ryne Sherman, PhD, chief science officer, andย Blake Loepp, PR manager, spoke withย Aiyesha Dey, PhD, associate professor of business administration at Harvard Business School, about howย CEO personalityย influences CEO behaviour.

By researching the personal lives of CEOs and their behaviour outside of the workplace, Aiyesha has identified data that can be quite predictive of how they may perform on the job.

Letโ€™s dive into how the personality characteristics of materialism and rule breaking can affectย CEO behaviour.

CEO Personality Matters

Even with systemic fixes and the right incentives, not everyone will behave the same. Thatโ€™s why corporate scandals still occur despite layers of regulation. Individual managerial styles matter.

โ€œWe know managers matter, but what about them is important?โ€ Aiyesha asked. โ€œWhat should we care about, and how does it matter for corporate outcomes?โ€ Those questions inspired her research into about 1,000 public companies and executives in the US. Her findings? Certain personality characteristics, observable in off-the-job lifestyles of executives, correlate with actions executives take within organisations.

Regulators can step in and uncover fraud and scandals after theyโ€™ve already taken placeโ€”after shareholders have lost resources and employees have lost jobs. The goal of looking at lifestyles of executives is to know some indicators of risk beforehand. Stopping these actions before they take place by using an empirical measure ofย characterย is the underlying motivation driving the research.

Understanding CEO Risk Factors

Aiyeshaโ€™s research has shown two characteristics that could lead to major corporate blunders: materialism and an inclination toward rule breaking. However, organisations often ignore evidence of these values when hiring CEOs, especially for internal hires. Why?

First, thereโ€™s no need to dismiss a CEO candidate because they have multiple luxury assets or a few speeding tickets. They likely bring many other desirable strengths to the table, such as innovation, creativity, and a certainย comfort with risk.

โ€œBut leaders can be a strong force in establishing the culture of the firm,โ€ Aiyesha pointed out. Someone who breaks rules might inspire a culture that rewards rule breaking, for instance.

Most firms focus on education, experience, and accomplishments in selection. Including behavioural attributes in selection criteria can add to the educational and professional qualifications already in consideration. โ€œBoards can definitely take more cautionary measures in their hiring practices, like expanding background checks for internal candidates,โ€ Aiyesha added.

Repeated legal infractions or a lifestyle of conspicuous consumption are not reasons to dismiss a candidate. Candidates with these behavioural attributes bring very strong upsides to the table, but the attributes can be warning signs about questionable behaviour or values. Knowing what strengths andย potential shortcomingsย a person brings to the role is the first step in establishing a system or process to mitigate the individualโ€™s risks.

CEO Behaviour: Materialism

Measuring materialism in a CEO can be a challenge. For one, the signs must be observable. For another, the signs must be indicative of values, which is more difficult to discern.

When psychology researchers talk about materialism, they mean a set of values that define how individuals weigh intrinsic motivations, such as spirituality, benevolence, or community, relative to extrinsic motivations, such as image, status, or material possessions. โ€œA very materialistic person will seek material acquisitions at the cost of community values,โ€ Aiyesha said.

Merely possessing a lot of luxury goods is not sufficient to make one materialistic. โ€œWhen someone has a zeal to pursue material possessions at the cost of the welfare of others and potentially themselves, they are exemplifying a materialistic value system,โ€ Aiyesha said. The observable assets of executives like houses, cars, and yachts compared to their wealth level shows how intent they are on acquiring material possessions. If someone possesses five times the value of luxury assets as another person at the same wealth level, then itโ€™s safe to say they probably have a tendency towards materialism.

Materialism is potentially a problem in a corporate setting if a CEO is willing to waste shareholder resources or damage the welfare of others to get material goods. This value held by a leader affects the values of the organisation, as well.

CEO Behaviour: Rule Breaking

Like materialism, external rule-breaking behaviour speaks to internal values. The underlying construct is a lack of self-control and disregard for rules and laws. If you believe rules donโ€™t apply to you, youโ€™ll be more likely to violate them to achieve your goals.

In looking at executivesโ€™ legal records, Aiyesha found that executives with legal infractions had a higher propensity to commit fraud and manipulate earnings numbers than those without. The results were true even for executives with only traffic or speeding violations. โ€œEven minor violations can give an indication of deeperย personalityย differences,โ€ Aiyesha observed.

Hereโ€™s a twist: executives with prior legal infractions tend to be involved in committing the fraud themselves, while materialistic executives tend to create a culture where other people are implicated in the fraud.

Given that corporate fraud is an extremely rare event, Aiyesha also looked at the tendency to profit from insider trading. Rule-breaking CEOs profited more; the outsized profitability and lucrative timing suggest that they could have benefited unfairly. There also seems to be a correlation between these profits and the severity of the legal infractionโ€”the more severe, the more profitable.

So, what should organisations do?

How to Hire a CEO

Based on Aiyeshaโ€™s research findings, these are the steps that organisations hiring for C-suite positions can take.

In general, boards should not dismiss a candidate simply due to luxury possessions or speeding tickets. They should, however, be aware of the risks that could point to a red flag.

Expanding selection criteria to include background checks and looking at behavioural attributes in addition to professional successes could be useful. Where necessary, organisations can also implement risk management and compliance measures as guardrails. Lastly, organisations can also help executives toย develop strategic self-awarenessย and encourage them to define personal guardrails to manage their behaviour.

A Vote for CEO Frugality

โ€œI want to end on a positive note and celebrate another characteristic that is linked to materialism. The opposite of materialism is frugality,โ€ Aiyesha said. โ€œOur research shows very strong consistent results of how frugal executives benefit companies in terms of stewardship of shareholder resources.โ€

Theย values of leadersย set the culture of organisations. Materialistic or rule-breaking CEOs can tacitly foster an environment of materialism and rule breaking. Frugal CEOs, on the other hand, tend to have tighter controls and risk management systems. They tend to take a long-term focus and shape ethical cultures. These CEOs tend to focus on socially responsible activities.

โ€œCreating a culture of frugality in organisations, either through hiring that mindset or by celebrating such an attitude so that it inspires everyone to have this notion, can take companies a long way in creating shareholder values,โ€ Aiyesha said.

Listen to this conversation in full onย episode 58ย ofย The Science of Personality.

Contact us for more informationย Learn about the Hogan 360

References

This blog post was originally posted byย Hogan Assessments

TOPIC AREA

coaching, leader development, leadership, Personality

DATE POSTED

August 31, 2022

SHARE ON YOUR SOCIALS

Latest blog posts

Loading...

The Dark Side of Creativity: How Imagination Derails Performance

Predicting Athletic Performance with Personality Assessment

PBC Webinar – Measuring What Matters: A Smarter Way to Lead Safer Workplaces

Webinar: Customising the Hogan 360: Why, When and How

Enabling the SES Performance Leadership Framework through leveraging the Hogan 360 in Development

Questions?

Weโ€™re here
to help.

Contact Us

Get certified
today

Gain comprehensive training on how to use Hoganโ€™s personality assessments

Get Certified Now

Related Articles

The Dark Side of Creativity: How Imagination Derails Performance

Most of us have encountered a leader who uses meetings as personal brainstorming time. Everyone leaves feeling confused or uncertain…
Read More

Predicting Athletic Performance with Personality Assessment

Can personality predict the success of professional athletes? Whether helping NBA teams predict rookie-year performance or NFL teams perfect their…
Read More

PBC Webinar – Measuring What Matters: A Smarter Way to Lead Safer Workplaces

๐Ÿ“…30 October 2025 ๐Ÿ•‘10:00-11:00 AM (AEDT) | 12:00-1:00 PM (NZDT) Join Dr. Xander Van Lill and Andrew Morris on 30…
Read More
View All

Stay connected

Copyright 2024 Peter Berry Consultancy.

Sydney

Level 8/201 Miller Street,
North Sydney, NSW 2060 Australia

Phone: +61 2 8918 0888

Peter Berry Consultancy wishes to acknowledge the Traditional Custodians the Cammeraygal and their Country on which we work today.

See map

Melbourne

Suite 303, 430 Little Collins Street, Melbourne, VIC, 3000 Australia

Phone: +61 3 8629 5100

Peter Berry Consultancy wishes to acknowledge the Traditional Custodians the Boon Wurrung and Woiwurrung (Wurundjeri) peoples of the Kulin Nation and their Country on which we work today.

See map

Auckland

11 Britomart Place, Auckland CBD,
Auckland 1010, New Zealand

Phone: +64 9 941 9790

See map

Ireland

Suite 301, 53 Merrion Square South, Dublin 2, D02 PR63, Ireland

Phone: +353 1 578 3607

See map
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY – AU
  • PRIVACY POLICY โ€“ NZ
  • COOKIES POLICY
  • EU COMPLIANCE
Peter Berry Consultancy
Manage Consent

PBC uses cookies. Learn more about our policies by clicking the links below.

Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}